Pet Insurance Disputes
A denied or underpaid pet insurance claim can leave you with a large veterinary bill and a policy you no longer trust. Disputes often turn on medical history, policy language and when a condition first appeared.
Robinson Investigations & Conflict Resolution provides neutral mediation and arbitration for pet owners, animal-related businesses and insurers, plus claim fact-finding for Virginia matters.
Insurance disputes we handle
- Pet insurance claims denied or only partly paid
- Coverage disputes, including exclusions and pre-existing conditions
- Breach of contract under an animal insurance policy
- Alleged bad-faith claim handling
- Insurance disputes involving kennels, boarding facilities, groomers and other animal businesses
- Insurance claim fact-finding (Virginia only)
How we help
- Mediation. A confidential negotiation that can settle a claim without a lawsuit.
- Arbitration. A neutral decision when the policy or a separate agreement calls for one.
- Claim fact-finding. For Virginia matters, we review the policy, claim file, veterinary records and timeline, and interview witnesses. Both sides receive a clear, neutral account of the facts.
How it works
- Free consultation. A 30-minute meeting by secure video. Have the policy, the denial letter and the claim history ready.
- Case assessment. We identify the disputed facts and the best process.
- Mediation, arbitration or fact-finding. By secure video or in person in Virginia.
- Resolution. A settlement, award or neutral report.
Where we serve
Mediation and arbitration serve Virginia and Washington, DC residents when at least one party is a Virginia resident, or the dispute arises from a contract, property or transaction located in Virginia. For a business, residency means it is organized under
Virginia law or has its principal place of business in Virginia. Fact-finding is for Virginia matters only.
Fees
Rates range from $400 to $600 per hour depending on complexity, divided equally among the parties unless they agree otherwise in writing. A non-refundable $150 case-opening fee applies once the case file is opened. If an insurer’s or business’s contract requires a consumer to mediate or arbitrate, the consumer pays only the $150 fee and the business pays the rest. See Our Fees for full terms.
Why Robinson Conflict Resolution
Robinson Investigations and Conflict Resolution, LLC was founded by Scharn Robinson, JD, PhD, a former federal prosecutor. She is a member of the Academy of Court-Appointed Neutrals, a Supreme Court of Virginia Certified Mediator with additional specialized certifications in family mediation, and a University of Maryland, Francis King Carey School of Law trained arbitrator. She is also a member of the Virginia Mediation Network. Our firm handles animal-related disputes exclusively.
Breeder dispute FAQ
We can mediate or arbitrate the dispute with the insurer if both sides agree to participate. For advice about your rights under the policy, consult an attorney or your state insurance regulator.
Yes. Insurers and animal businesses can engage us, and our process is neutral for every party.
The policy and any riders, the denial letter, full veterinary records, invoices and all correspondence with the insurer.
Book a Free Consultation by Secure Video
Fill out an initial intake form and email it to ADR@robinsonconflictresolution.com, or call (877) 309-1687.
Robinson Investigations & Conflict Resolution, LLC is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Our services are limited to independent investigations, mediation, arbitration and related alternative dispute resolution services.
Start with a conversation
Free 30-minute consultation
By secure video.