This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time. Robinson Investigations & Conflict Resolution LLC provides resolution services; for advice about your specific rights, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
Step 1: Get your dog veterinary care
Your pet’s health comes first. A full exam also creates the medical record you will need later. Litigation for Animal Welfare recommends a complete veterinary exam and keeping every record and invoice.
Step 2: Document everything right away with a mind toward mediation or arbitration
As the same source puts it, “Injuries heal fast. You need proof.” Collect:
Dated photos and videos of the injuries
All vet records, test results, and receipts
The boarding contract and any waiver you signed
Names of staff you spoke with and the times of each conversation
Photos showing your dog’s condition before drop-off, if you have them
Texts, emails, or daily “report cards” the facility sent
Step 3: Ask for the facility’s records in writing
Request the incident report and internal notes, and ask whether video exists. Litigation for Animal Welfare advises doing this “in writing” and asking “for all internal documentation.” Ask quickly, because many camera systems record over old footage. If your pet died, an independent necropsy (animal autopsy) can help establish the cause.
Step 4: Understand Virginia law
Dogs are property. Under Va. Code § 3.2-6585, dogs and cats are “personal property,” and an owner whose pet is injured or killed may recover “the value thereof or the damage done thereto.” In practice, that usually means veterinary costs and the animal’s value, not emotional distress. The Animal Legal & Historical Center notes that most states, and Virginia is not among the exceptions it lists, reject recovery for loss of companionship.
Bailment and negligence. When you leave your dog with a business, the law generally treats it as a “bailment”: the facility takes temporary custody and must use reasonable care. Courts in some jurisdictions have held that a healthy pet returned injured, or not returned at all, raises a presumption of negligence. A New York court did so in Brousseau v. Rosenthal (1980), shifting the burden to the kennel to prove it used due care. FindLaw also lists breach of contract and negligence per se (a violation of law) as possible claims.
Waivers. Virginia has an unusual rule. In Hiett v. Lake Barcroft Community Ass’n, 244 Va. 191 (1992), the Supreme Court of Virginia held that pre-injury releases of personal injury claims are void: “Public policy forbids it, and contracts against public policy are void.” However, the Court has upheld advance limits on liability for property damage. In Nido v. Ocean Owners’ Council, 237 Va. 664 (1989), it enforced a condominium provision limiting liability for water damage to units, and Hiett itself distinguished such property cases. Because a pet is property (Va. Code § 3.2-6585), a boarding waiver may limit a claim for your dog’s injuries. As a general rule, though, waivers typically do not protect against gross negligence or intentional harm (FindLaw; Litigation for Animal Welfare).
If you were the one injured. If you were bitten or knocked down while dropping off or picking up your dog, the Hiett rule means a Virginia facility’s waiver likely cannot bar your personal injury claim.
Maryland and D.C. notes
Maryland and DC also generally treat pets as property for damages purposes. Maryland caps compensatory damages for tortious injury to or death of a pet at $25,000, up from $10,000 as of October 1, 2025 (Chapter 100 of 2025). Waivers are more commonly enforced there than in Virginia, but, as Litigation for Animal Welfare notes, waivers “do not protect businesses from gross negligence, fraud, or breach of contract.”
Step 5: Know the cost-benefit math
A lawsuit can easily cost more than a pet claim is worth. If you do go to court, small claims is often the right forum:
| Jurisdiction | Small claims limit | Source |
| Virginia | $5,000 (general district court handles up to $50,000) | Va. Code § 16.1-122.2; Va. Code § 16.1-77 |
| Maryland | $5,000 | Maryland People’s Law Library |
| District of Columbia | $10,000 | DC Courts |
Step 6: Try to resolve the dispute through mediation or arbitration
Send a calm, written demand. Describe what happened, attach vet bills, and state what you want (reimbursement, a refund, a policy change).
Check the contract for a dispute clause. Some agreements require mediation or arbitration first.
Propose mediation or arbitration. A neutral helps both sides talk through what happened and reach a practical settlement.
For help resolving disputes involving veterinary care, boarding, or daycare facilities, learn more about our Veterinary & Boarding Disputes services.
Contact Robinson Investigations & Conflict Resolution LLC
Keep court as your fallback, not your opening move.
Why mediation and arbitration work well here
Boarding and daycare businesses depend on reputation and repeat customers, so they have reason to settle fairly and privately. Mediation or arbitration can also deliver things a court cannot order, like an apology, an explanation, or changes in supervision practices. In Virginia, mediation communications are confidential under Va. Code § 8.01-576.10, and a mediated agreement “is enforceable as a contract” (Virginia Court System). If the parties prefer a neutral decision-maker to a negotiated deal, arbitration is another private option: under Virginia law, a written agreement to arbitrate is “valid, enforceable and irrevocable” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.01), and a court-confirmed award is “docketed and enforced as any other judgment or decree” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.012).
Sources
Va. Code § 3.2-6585, Dogs and cats deemed personal property, Virginia Law (LIS)
Hiett v. Lake Barcroft Community Ass’n, 244 Va. 191, 418 S.E.2d 894 (1992), Justia
Nido v. Ocean Owners’ Council, 237 Va. 664, 378 S.E.2d 837 (1989), Justia
Va. Code § 16.1-122.2, Small claims jurisdiction, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 16.1-77, Civil jurisdiction of general district courts, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 8.01-581.01, Validity of arbitration agreement, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 8.01-581.012, Judgment or decree on award, Virginia Law (LIS)
Chapter 100 (SB 581), 2025 Session, Maryland General Assembly
Small Claims, Maryland People’s Law Library
Small Claims, District of Columbia Courts
Frequently Asked Questions About Mediation, Virginia Court System
Boarding and Daycare Disasters, Litigation for Animal Welfare
Can I Sue a Dog Kennel, Pet Boarding Facility, or Dog Day Care?, FindLaw
Brousseau v. Rosenthal, 110 Misc. 2d 1054 (N.Y. Civ. Ct. 1980), Animal Legal & Historical Center
Overview of Damages for Injury to Animals, Animal Legal & Historical Center
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction about your specific situation.
Veterinary Malpractice: Are Mediation and Arbitration Faster Alternatives to a Lawsuit?
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time. Robinson Investigations & Conflict Resolution LLC provides resolution services; for advice about your specific rights, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
For many Virginia pet owners, yes. A veterinary malpractice lawsuit usually requires expert testimony and can take months or years, and Virginia law bars recovery for emotional distress. Mediation and arbitration both resolve disputes privately and are usually faster. Mediation lets you and the clinic shape your own agreement; arbitration gives you a binding decision from a neutral without going to court.
What you must prove in a malpractice case
According to the Animal Legal & Historical Center at Michigan State University College of Law, a veterinary malpractice claim has four elements:
Duty: the vet accepted your animal as a patient.
Breach: the vet failed to use “the same skill and knowledge normally possessed by veterinarians in good standing in similar communities.”
Causation: that failure caused the injury or death.
Damages: you suffered a measurable loss.
Expert testimony from another veterinarian is generally required, because the standard of care is “outside the common experience and knowledge of lay jurors.” Those same elements matter whether a claim is decided by a judge, a jury, or an arbitrator.
What you can recover in Virginia
Virginia treats pets as personal property (Va. Code § 3.2-6585). Two Virginia cases define the limits:
No emotional distress damages. In Kondaurov v. Kerdasha, 271 Va. 646 (2006), the Supreme Court of Virginia held that “the law in Virginia, as in most states that have decided the question, regards animals, however beloved, as personal property.” Allowing emotional distress damages, the court said, “would amount to a sweeping change in the law of damages, a subject properly left to legislative consideration.”
Vet bills can exceed the pet’s market value. In Blue Pearl Veterinary Partners, LLC v. Anderson (Va. Ct. App. July 11, 2023), a golden retriever the owner bought for $350 suffered leg fractures during a CT scan. The Court of Appeals of Virginia held that the owner may recover veterinary expenses she can prove were “reasonably and necessarily incurred” because of the clinic’s negligence, even above market value, calling the usual damages rules “a standard, not a shackle.”
Maryland and D.C. notes
Maryland caps compensatory damages for tortious injury to or death of a pet. Under “Buddy’s Law” (Chapter 100 of 2025), the cap rose from $10,000 to $25,000 effective October 1, 2025. Recoverable amounts include the pet’s fair market value and reasonable and necessary veterinary care (Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 11-110; this FindLaw copy may still show the old $10,000 figure).
A licensing complaint won’t get you reimbursed
Filing with the licensing board can matter for accountability, but it does not compensate you:
| Jurisdiction | Where to complain | Can it award money? |
| Virginia | Board of Veterinary Medicine, via the Department of Health Professions | No: “DHP does not have the authority to require a licensee to return money or provide other personal remedies” (DHP) |
| Maryland | State Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners | No: the Board “cannot order a veterinarian to waive charges, refund money paid, or award damages” (Maryland Dept. of Agriculture) |
| District of Columbia | DC Health, Board of Veterinary Medicine | No: the Board lacks “the legal authority to order reimbursement, awards or damages”; review takes up to 120 days (DC Health) |
Maryland’s board notes that investigations can take months to over a year, and it points owners with money concerns toward a private attorney or voluntary mediation.
Better Options – Mediation or Arbitration
| Lawsuit | Mediation | Arbitration | |
| Who decides | Judge or jury | You and the clinic, together | A neutral arbitrator |
| Binding? | Yes, subject to appeal | Only if you sign an agreement, which “is enforceable as a contract” (Virginia Court System) | Yes; a confirmed award is enforced “as any other judgment or decree” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.012) |
| Public or private | Public court record | Confidential under Va. Code § 8.01-576.10 | Held privately, outside open court |
| Possible outcomes | Money damages | Anything both sides accept: payment, bill reduction, apology, procedure changes | An award decided by the arbitrator |
| Challenging the result | Appeal | Not applicable | Very limited grounds (Va. Code § 8.01-581.010) |
Why mediation is often the best first step
The American Veterinary Medical Association recommends starting by talking with your veterinarian, noting that “Many times, what’s perceived as an error is actually a failure of communication.” Mediation builds on that idea with a neutral third party. It offers:
Speed: sessions can be scheduled in weeks, not the months or years a lawsuit can take.
Lower cost: often no need for expert reports or trial preparation.
Confidentiality: in Virginia, mediation communications are confidential under Va. Code § 8.01-576.10 (Virginia Court System).
Enforceable results: a mediated agreement “is enforceable as a contract” (same source).
Remedies a court can’t order: an explanation of what happened, an apology, a bill reduction, or changes in clinic procedures.
The Virginia court system also reports that “Over 90% of parties using mediation are satisfied with the process, would use it again in the future and would recommend it to others.”
When arbitration makes sense
Arbitration is a good fit when you want a final answer from a neutral but would rather avoid court. It can be especially useful when talks have stalled, when the facts are disputed, or when both sides want a decision-maker who understands veterinary issues.
You can agree to it after the dispute arises. Virginia enforces both a written agreement “to submit any existing controversy to arbitration” and an arbitration clause for future disputes; either is “valid, enforceable and irrevocable” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.01).
Check your paperwork. Some service agreements or intake forms include an arbitration clause. If yours does, it may require arbitration instead of a lawsuit.
The award is final. A court must vacate an award only on narrow grounds, such as fraud, arbitrator partiality or misconduct, or an arbitrator exceeding their powers. The statute adds that the fact the relief “could not or would not be granted by a court of law or equity is not grounds for vacating or refusing to confirm the award” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.010).
It is enforceable. Once confirmed, the award is “docketed and enforced as any other judgment or decree” (Va. Code § 8.01-581.012).
Because an award is so hard to overturn, read any arbitration agreement carefully before you sign it. Many parties try mediation first and agree to arbitrate only the issues they cannot settle.
Practical steps to prepare for mediation or arbitration
Request a complete copy of your pet’s medical records.
Get a second opinion from another veterinarian.
Keep all invoices and a timeline of events.
Check any forms you signed for an arbitration or dispute resolution clause.
Raise your concerns with the vet or practice manager in writing.
Propose mediation, with arbitration as the next step if you cannot reach agreement.
Sources
Detailed Discussion of Veterinarian Malpractice, Animal Legal & Historical Center
Va. Code § 3.2-6585, Virginia Law (LIS)
Kondaurov v. Kerdasha, 271 Va. 646, 629 S.E.2d 181 (2006), CourtListener
Blue Pearl Veterinary Partners, LLC v. Anderson, Record No. 1180-22-1 (Va. Ct. App. July 11, 2023), Justia
Va. Code § 8.01-581.01, Validity of arbitration agreement, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 8.01-581.010, Vacating an award, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 8.01-581.012, Judgment or decree on award, Virginia Law (LIS)
Va. Code § 8.01-576.10, Confidentiality of dispute resolution proceedings, Virginia Law (LIS)
Frequently Asked Questions About Mediation, Virginia Court System
File a Complaint, Virginia Department of Health Professions
Filing a Complaint, Maryland State Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners
Veterinarian Complaint Review and Investigations Process, DC Health
Chapter 100 (SB 581), 2025 Session, Maryland General Assembly
Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 11-110, FindLaw
Complaints against veterinarians, American Veterinary Medical Association
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction about your specific situation.